Friday, November 11, 2016

On Dividing Americans


A real flaw in the election system as it exists is that it narrows us down to two parties.  Oh sure, there was a Green candidate, an Independent, etc. but they don’t even register as a blip when you look at the national results on the whole.  I’ve been told that there are countries where if party A wins 35%, and party B wins 23%, and party C wins 7%...party A’s candidate will be the leader, but votes for the others are the percentages that their votes on policy through the upcoming term will merit. No one remains unrepresented.  Not sure if it’s true, but it sounds mighty civilized.

But here we are, limited to the Democrat or Republican party.  It basically forces us to choose between two teams: seemingly two absolutes.  Us versus Them.  When in reality Americans, humans – are not that easy to divide.  We are complex beings with wide ranging experiences and unique personal histories that inform our personal values.  This isn’t sports – heck, even in sports people have different reasons for supporting a particular team or the other.  But right now that is the mindset that many Americans are stuck in. 

  • If you voted for Trump, you’re prejudiced! (Against gays, Mexicans, Muslims, the disabled, etc.)
  • If you voted for Hillary, you must support Wall Street!
  • If you voted for Trump, you must be okay with sexual assault.
  • If you voted for Hillary Clinton, you must support late term abortions! 
  • If you’re a Republican – you favor tax breaks for the wealthiest at the expense of the rest of America!
  • If you’re Liberal, you just want to smoke pot and leech off of tax payer dollars!


The truth is, we cannot be boxed up neatly into two categories and this deep division without real conversation aimed at true understanding, does not help any of us.  There are Hillary supporters who think Wall Street as it stands is vile.  There are Trump supporters who contribute money to ACLU, NAACP, and other human rights organizations.  There are liberals who are opposed to the recreational use of marijuana while there are conservatives that support medical use.  There are so many variances that it would be impossible to find a perfect candidate that matched our vision and values item for item.

There are in fact people who voted for Trump based solely on the fact that his name is familiar and rings of success – who have no idea that he has made very un-American comments at his rallies but would adamantly stand up for the rights of those who are less privileged. 
There are millions of people in this country that have never talked to a refugee or a Muslim – who don’t know that their student’s best friend is undocumented, that their favorite teacher or boss is gay, or that their heart surgeon was an asylee. (Yes, they should...but for whatever reason they don't or haven't.)

There are people who don’t really understand what the email thing was actually about.  They only know what they keep hearing repeated, “They are taking your jobs!” or “She is being investigated for…”  Those who voted for Trump are not necessarily evil.  They’re not all deplorable.  Those who voted for Hillary are not necessarily heathens with no morals.  You can’t even look at an entire state or city and lump all of their votes as being for one candidate or another either as I keep seeing in some memes. 

We can’t make broad assumptions about others.  Even you, reading this may be wholeheartedly opposed to a Trump presidency but agree with a number of his ideas (term limits, revising NAFTA, refusing the TPP, etc.)  And you may not like the way Hillary feels about education reform you might agree with her on some other issues (autism, gun violence, minimum wage).  We cannot oversimplify one another. 

More than ever it is essential that we talk with one another.  Openly, honestly – not with an interest in finding our differences, but with a determination to find our similarities.  Only through an understanding of those who are very different from us can we grow and improve.  Without judgement, but with a deep desire for a better life for everyone in our communities.   Then we can begin to resoundingly speak out to these elected officials for the things that we most strongly agree on, and come up with ideas for workable solutions on the things we don’t. 


1 comment: